| There are many myths about
wind energy. Below are the facts:
Myth: Tens of thousands of wind turbines will be cluttering
the British countryside
Fact: Government legislation requires that by 2010, 10% of
electricity supply must come from renewable sources. Wind
power is currently the most cost effective renewable energy
source in a position to help do that. Around 3,500 of additional
modern wind turbines are all that would be needed to deliver
8% of the UK's electricity by 2010, roughly 2,000 onshore
and 1,500 offshore.
Myth: Wind farms won't help climate change
Fact: Wind power is a clean, renewable source of energy which
produces no greenhouse gas emissions or waste products. The
UK currently emits 560 million tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2),
the key greenhouse gas culprit, every year and the Government
target is to cut this by 60% by 2050 1. Power stations are
the largest contributor to carbon emissions, producing 170
million tonnes of CO2 each year 2. We need to switch to forms
of energy that do not produce CO2. Just one modern wind turbine
will save over 4,000 tonnes of CO2 emissions annually.
Myth: Building a wind farm takes more energy than
it ever makes
Fact: The average wind farm will pay back the energy used
in its manufacture within 3-5 months of operation. This compares
favourably with coal or nuclear power stations, which take
about six months. A modern wind turbine is designed to operate
for more than 20 years and at the end of its working life,
the area can be restored at low financial and environmental
costs. Wind energy is a form of development which is essentially
reversible - in contrast to fossil fuel or nuclear power stations.
Myth: Wind farms are inefficient, they are only operational
30% of the time
Fact: A modern wind turbine produces electricity 70-85% of
the time, but it generates different outputs dependent on
wind speed. Over the course of a year, it will generate about
30% of the theoretical maximum output. This is known as its
load factor. The load factor of conventional power stations
is on average 50%. A modern wind turbine will generate enough
to meet the electricity demands of more than a thousand homes
over the course of a year.
Myth: Wind energy needs back-up to work
Fact: All forms of power generation require back up and no
energy technology can be relied upon 100%. The UK's transmission
system already operates with enough back-up to manage the
instantaneous loss of a large power station. Variations in
the output from wind farms are barely noticeable over and
above the normal fluctuation in supply and demand, seen when
the nation's workforce goes home, or if lightning brings down
a high-voltage transmission line. Therefore, at present there
is no need for additional back-up because of wind energy.
Even for wind power to provide 10% of our nation's electricity
needs, only a small amount of additional conventional back-up
would be required, in the region of 300-500 MW. This would
add only 0.2 pence per kilowatt hour to the generation cost
of wind energy and would not in any way threaten the security
of our grid. In fact, this is unlikely to become a significant
issue until wind generates over 20% of total electricity supply.
Myth: Installing wind farms will never shut other
power stations
Fact: The simple fact is that power plants in the UK are being
shut down either through European legislation on emissions
or sheer old age. We need to act now to find replacement power
sources: wind is an abundant resource, indigenous to the UK
and therefore has a vital role to play in the new energy portfolio.
Myth: Wind power is expensive
Fact: The cost of generating electricity from wind has fallen
dramatically over the past few years. Between 1990 and 2002,
world wind energy capacity doubled every three years and with
every doubling prices fell by 15%. Wind energy is competitive
with new coal and new nuclear capacity, even before any environmental
costs of fossil fuel and nuclear generation are taken into
account. The average cost of generating electricity from onshore
wind is now around 3-4p per kilowatt hour, competitive with
new coal (2.5-4.5p) and cheaper than new nuclear (4-7p). As
gas prices increase and wind power costs fall - both of which
are very likely - wind becomes even more competitive, so much
so that some time after 2010 wind should challenge gas as
the lowest cost power source.
Furthermore, the wind is a free and widely available fuel
source, therefore once the wind farm is in place, there are
no fuel or waste related costs.
Myth: The UK should invest in other renewable energy
technologies and energy efficiency instead of wind power
Fact: Wind energy's role in combating climate change is not
a matter of either-or. The UK will need a mix of new and existing
renewable energy technologies and energy efficiency measures,
and as quickly as possible. Significant amounts of investment
have been allocated for wave and tidal energy development,
and these technologies, along with solar and biomass energy,
will have an important role in the UK's future energy mix.
However, wind energy is the most cost effective renewable
energy source available to generate clean electricity and
help combat climate change right now. Furthermore, developing
a strong wind industry will facilitate other renewable technologies
which have not reached commercialisation yet, accumulating
valuable experience in dealing with issues such as grid connection,
supply chain and finance.
Myth: Wind farms should all be put out at sea
Fact: We will need a mix of both onshore and offshore wind
energy to meet the UK's challenging targets on climate change.
At present, onshore wind is more economical than development
offshore. However, more offshore wind farms are now under
construction, with the first of the large-scale projects operational
at the end of 2003, and prices will fall as the industry gains
more experience. Furthermore, offshore wind farms will take
longer to develop, as the sea is inherently a more hostile
environment. To expect offshore to be the only form of wind
generation allowed would therefore be to condemn us to missing
our renewable energy targets and commitment to tackle climate
change.
Myth: Wind farms are ugly and unpopular
Fact: Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and whether you
think a wind turbine is attractive or not will always be your
personal opinion. However, studies regularly show that most
people find turbines an interesting feature of the landscape.
On average 80% of the public support wind energy, less than
10% are against it, the remainder are undecided. Surveys conducted
since the early 1990's across the country near existing wind
farms have consistently found that most people are in favour
of wind energy, with support increasing among those living
near existing wind farms.
Myth: Wind farms negatively affect tourism
Fact: There is no evidence to suggest this. The UK's first
commercial wind farm at Delabole received 350,000 visitors
in its first ten years of operation. A MORI poll in Scotland
showed that 80% of tourists would be interested in visiting
a wind farm. Furthermore, wind farm developers are often asked
to provide a visitor centre, viewing platforms and rights
of way to their sites.
Myth: Wind farms harm property prices
Fact: There is currently no evidence in the UK showing that
wind farms impact house prices. However, there is evidence
following a comprehensive study by the Scottish Executive
that those living nearest to wind farms are their strongest
advocates.
Myth: Wind farms kill birds
Fact: The RSPB stated in its 2004 information leaflet Wind
farms and birds, that "in the UK, we have not so far
witnessed any major adverse effects on birds associated with
wind farms". Wind farms are always subject to an Environmental
Impact Assessment. BWEA members follow Best Practice Guidelines
and work closely with organisations such as English Nature
and the RSPB to ensure that wind farm design and layout does
not interfere with sensitive species or wildlife designated
sites. Furthermore, a recent report published in the journal
Nature confirmed that the greatest threat to bird populations
in the UK is climate change.
Myth: Wind farms are dangerous to humans
Fact: Wind energy is a benign technology with no associated
emissions, harmful pollutants or waste products. In over 25
years and with more than 68,000 machines installed around
the world, no member of the public has ever been harmed by
wind turbines. In response to recent unscientific accusations
that wind turbines emit infrasound and cause associated health
problems, Dr Geoff Leventhall, Consultant in Noise Vibration
and Acoustics and author of the Defra Report on Low Frequency
Noise and its Effects 16, says: "I can state quite categorically
that there is no significant infrasound from current designs
of wind turbines. To say that there is an infrasound problem
is one of the hares which objectors to wind farms like to
run. There will not be any effects from infrasound from the
turbines."
Myth: Wind farms are noisy
Fact: The evolution of wind farm technology over the past
decade has rendered mechanical noise from turbines almost
undetectable with the main sound being the aerodynamic swoosh
of the blades passing the tower. There are strict guidelines
on wind turbines and noise emissions to ensure the protection
of residential amenity. These are contained in the scientifically
informed ETSU Working Group guidelines 1996 17 and must be
followed by wind farm developers, as referenced in national
planning policy for renewables 18. The best advice for any
doubter is to go and hear for yourself!
Note: The 'average modern wind turbine' being referred
to in this document has a rated capacity of 1.8 megawatts
(MW) onshore. With the data of approvals and applications
currently available for future wind farms we know this will
increase to 2+ MW. Offshore, turbines currently being installed
are rated at 3 MW, while it is expected that offshore machines
being installed by 2010 will typically be around 5 MW
|